How can one determine whether a replacement grounding clamp is still within the scope of existing IEC 61230 test evidence?
When a supplier proposes using a different grounding clamp to replace the originally approved model, the purchaser cannot simply rely on the original IEC 61230 test report. Instead, the purchaser must first verify the structure, connection method, electrical conductivity, and interaction with other components of the replacement clamp before confirming whether the original test report covers the modified configuration. If the original report does not sufficiently demonstrate that the new configuration meets the specified requirements for short-circuit current, duration, and peak factor, the manufacturer must provide supplementary technical evidence or an appropriate validation plan, which must undergo the technical approval process specified by the project before the equipment can be approved for use.
The key issue is not whether the new clamp can be installed, but whether the original test evidence remains applicable to the modified, complete earthing assembly.
Why Can an Alternative Earthing Clamp Affect Existing Test Evidence?
Portable earthing and short-circuiting equipment consists of multiple interconnected components. Depending on the specific configuration, it typically includes:
- Phase Clamp / Line Clamp
- Earth Clamp
- Earthing Cable
- Short-Circuiting Cable
- Cable Lug and Ferrule
- Connecting Cluster
- Conductive Extension
- Insulating Operating Components (where applicable)
These components collectively form a complete earthing or earthing short-circuiting assembly.
When a supplier proposes replacing one of the earthing clamps, the change may affect not only the clamp itself but also the cable terminations, the connection structure, and the electrical performance of the entire assembly.
For example, the original design used a bolted earthing clamp, while the supplier proposes replacing it with a spring-clamp design.
Even if both clamps can be installed at the same connection point, it cannot be automatically assumed that they have the same performance characteristics.
The following aspects must be considered:
Mechanical Compatibility: Can the new clamp be properly connected, and does it meet the mechanical stress requirements during normal operation?
Electrical Contact Performance: Do the contact interface and connection structure meet the corresponding electrical performance requirements?
Short-Circuit Withstand Capability: Can the replacement clamp and its connection components withstand the specified short-circuit current and the associated electrodynamic forces and thermal effects?
Assembly Compatibility: Does the new clamp form a validated configuration with the existing cables, terminals, and other connection components?
Test Evidence Applicability: Do the existing test reports cover the replaced components or the complete equipment?
The scope of IEC 61230:2008 includes portable temporary earthing and short-circuit equipment, as well as standalone components within the specified scope, such as clamps, cables, and their terminations. This standard addresses the electrodynamic and electrothermal effects generated during a short circuit and expresses the corresponding withstand capability in terms of rated current, time, and peak factor.
Therefore, a grounding clamp is not a standard mechanical component that can be evaluated in isolation from the complete connection assembly.
What Should Be Compared Between the Original and Alternative Clamps?
When evaluating an alternative solution proposed by a supplier, the first step is to establish a technical comparison between the Original Clamp and the Alternative Clamp.
The purchaser must not only compare product models, external dimensions, and maximum opening sizes but also examine the key structural features that affect the connection and performance.
Compare the Clamp Geometry and Connection Interface
It is recommended to first compare the following parameters:
| Comparison Item | Original Clamp | Alternative Clamp | What to Verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clamp Model | Originally Approved Model | New Model | Product Identification and Specifications |
| Jaw Geometry | Original Jaw Structure | New Jaw Structure | Clamping Method and Contact Location |
| Jaw Opening | Original Opening Range | New Opening Range | Actual Connection Point Compatibility |
| Contact Surface | Original Contact Surface | New Contact Surface | Contact Structure and Related Performance |
| Conductive Material | Original Conductive Material | New Conductive Material | Material and Performance Basis |
| Mounting Interface | Original Mounting Interface | New Mounting Interface | Connection Dimensions and Structure |
| Cable Connection | Original Cable Connection Method | New Connection Method | Termination Compatibility |
| Operating Mechanism | Original Operating Mechanism | New Operating Mechanism | Installation and Operating Conditions |
| Mechanical Design | Original Mechanical Structure | New Mechanical Structure | Basis for Mechanical Performance |
It is important to emphasize the following:
The same jaw opening does not imply identical electrical performance, nor does it guarantee full mechanical compatibility.
For example, two clamps may both have a maximum opening of 50 mm, but one uses a flat-contact design while the other employs a different clamping geometry.
While both may be installable at the same connection point, their contact conditions, force distribution, and connection performance may not be identical.
Similarly, even if the mounting hole positions of the new clamp are identical to those of the original model, this does not guarantee that their short-circuit withstand capacity is the same.
For further information on the relationship between clamp dimensions and connection points, refer to Portable Earthing Clamp Jaw Opening Selection.
Check the Cable and Terminal Connection
Replacement clamps may also alter the original cable termination configuration.
For example, the originally approved configuration may have used specific cable lugs and ferrules, while the new clamp uses different connection terminals.
In this case, even if the cable cross-sectional area remains unchanged, it is necessary to verify that the entire connection structure still meets the original design requirements.
Key points to verify:
- Cable Cross-Section: Conductor cross-sectional area.
- Cable Material: Conductor material (e.g., copper or aluminum).
- Lug Dimensions: Terminal lug dimensions.
- Ferrule Type: Crimp ferrule type.
- Connection Method: Bolted connection, crimping, or other connection methods.
- Fastening Structure: Fastening structure.
- Contact Interface: Actual conductive contact interface.
Do not arbitrarily drill holes, grind, cut, or add unapproved adapters to accommodate new fixtures.
If the alternative solution alters the cable termination, it should be evaluated as a comprehensive configuration change rather than simply recorded as a fixture model change.
Does the Original IEC 61230 Test Evidence Still Apply?
This is the most critical determination throughout the entire alternative fixture review process.
IEC 61230:2008 stipulates that grounding and earth-fault devices and related components shall have their electrical ratings determined based on the rated short-circuit current, duration, and corresponding peak factor.
For complete assemblies, their rated performance must be clearly specified; for standalone components, the corresponding ratings and test configurations must also be provided.
Therefore, the purchasing party must verify whether the original test reports truly cover the new clamp model and its connection configurations, rather than simply checking whether “IEC 61230” appears on the first page of the report.
Check the Rated Short-Circuit Current
Rated short-circuit current is one of the parameters that must be verified when evaluating replacement grounding clamps.
During a short-circuit, the clamp and its connection parts may be subjected to significant electrodynamic forces and thermal effects.
If the new clamp alters the conductive structure, contact interface, or connection method, it is necessary to confirm whether the relevant evidence still supports the rated short-circuit current of the original device.
The purchaser should verify:
- The Rated Current of the original grounding device.
- The rated performance data corresponding to the replacement clamp.
- The clamp model in the original test report.
- The cables and termination configurations used during testing.
- Technical differences between the old and new clamps.
- Validation criteria for the modified complete system.
One should not automatically assume that a new clamp has a higher short-circuit withstand capacity simply because it appears thicker, is heavier, or is made of a different metal.
Check the Rated Duration
Rated Duration is equally important.
The grounding device must withstand the corresponding electrical and mechanical stresses within the specified short-circuit duration.
For example, the rated conditions of the original device are:
- Rated Current: 31.5 kA
- Rated Duration: 1 s
- Rated Peak Factor: Determined according to approved technical specifications
The above is merely a hypothetical example and does not represent the actual rated parameters of any specific JINPOWER product.
If the replacement clamp alters the connection structure, the supplier must provide evidence demonstrating that the modified configuration still meets the original rated conditions.
It is not sufficient to merely prove that the clamp can make a connection during normal installation while ignoring performance requirements under short-circuit conditions.
Check the Rated Peak Factor
The Rated Peak Factor relates to the maximum peak current during the initial phase of a short circuit and the electrodynamic forces it generates.
Clamps and connection structures must be evaluated in conjunction with the corresponding short-circuit test conditions.
If a new clamp alters the clamping structure, mechanical constraints, or connection method, it must be confirmed whether the original test configuration still represents the actual replacement configuration.
Purchasers must not merely compare the Rated Current and Rated Duration while ignoring the peak factor and its corresponding validation conditions.
Understand the Difference Between Component and Assembly Evidence
This is where suppliers and purchasers most commonly get confused.
IEC 61230 permits the evaluation of individual components within the scope of the standard; however, test evidence for individual components cannot automatically serve as validation evidence for a complete grounding assembly.
For example:
The original complete assembly included:
- Clamp A
- Copper Cable
- Original Ferrule
- Connecting Cluster
The original report provided corresponding test evidence for this configuration.
Now the supplier proposes using Clamp B and has changed the ferrule.
Even if Clamp B has independent test data, it is still necessary to confirm:
- Whether the new clamp meets the applicable component requirements.
- Whether the new clamp is compatible with the new termination.
- Whether the electrical and mechanical performance of the connection has been fully verified.
- Whether the complete grounding assembly still meets its original rated performance.
Therefore, it is essential to distinguish between two types of evidence:
| Evidence Type | What It Demonstrates |
|---|---|
| Component Test Evidence | Performance of the corresponding individual component under the specified test configuration |
| Complete Assembly Test Evidence | Performance of the corresponding complete grounding assembly configuration |
The supplier shall clearly specify the models, components, connection configurations, and test conditions covered by the test reports.
A standalone test report for a single clamp cannot be used directly as proof that the modified grounding assembly as a whole meets all IEC 61230 requirements.
What Technical Evidence Should the Supplier Provide?
If the supplier wishes to use an alternative clamp, they must provide sufficient technical documentation to enable the purchaser to assess the differences between the new configuration and the originally approved configuration.
It is recommended that at least the following documents be prepared:
| Required Document | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Original Clamp Datasheet | To verify the technical specifications of the originally approved clamp |
| Alternative Clamp Datasheet | To verify the technical specifications of the alternative clamp |
| Original Assembly Drawing | Verify the original equipment structure |
| Revised Assembly Drawing | Confirm the complete revised structure |
| Original BOM | Confirm the original bill of materials |
| Revised BOM | Verify the revised bill of materials |
| Material Information | Verify conductive materials and materials for critical components |
| Connection Drawings | Verify cable and termination configurations |
| Component Test Evidence | Verify applicable test documentation for replacement components |
| Assembly Test Evidence | Verify test documentation for the complete assembly |
| Technical Equivalence Assessment | Explain the technical differences between the old and new components and the basis for equivalence |
| Configuration Revision Record | Record the approved configuration version |
Review the Original Test Report
The purchaser should not merely require the supplier to provide a single report marked with IEC 61230.
The purchaser should also verify the following:
- Report Number.
- Test Date.
- Tested Product Model.
- Clamp Model.
- Cable Specification.
- Terminal Configuration.
- Rated Current.
- Rated Duration.
- Rated Peak Factor.
- Test Arrangement.
- Test Results.
- Applicable Product Configuration.
If the report does not clearly specify the configuration of the test specimen, the supplier shall provide the necessary product identification and test data.
Review the Alternative Clamp Assessment
The supplier shall also provide a Technical Equivalence Assessment.
This document shall specify:
Original Configuration: The originally approved clamps and complete equipment configuration.
Proposed Configuration: The new clamps and their associated connection components.
Technical Differences: Differences between the old and new clamps in terms of materials, geometry, contact methods, mechanical structure, and connection interfaces.
Performance Assessment: Whether these changes affect the original electrical and mechanical performance.
Supporting Evidence: Which test reports, drawings, and technical documentation support the new configuration.
Conclusion: Is the existing evidence sufficient to support the new configuration, or is additional verification required?
Technical equivalence cannot rely solely on a statement from the supplier; it must be supported by technical documentation corresponding to the actual product configuration.
When Is Additional Testing or Verification Necessary?
Not all replacement fixtures require a complete re-test in accordance with IEC 61230.
Whether additional testing is required should be determined based on the nature of the changes, the scope of the original test report, standard requirements, and the project’s technical specifications.
Further evaluation is typically required in the following situations:
| Change Type | Required Review |
|---|---|
| Clamp model changed | Verify the new model and the scope of coverage of the original test report |
| Jaw geometry changed | Verify the clamping structure and contact performance |
| Conductive material changed | Verify the material and relevant electrical performance criteria |
| Contact interface changed | Verify connection and contact performance |
| Cable terminal changed | Verify the termination structure and applicable test evidence |
| Mechanical connection changed | Verify mechanical performance and connection reliability |
| Assembly configuration changed | Re-evaluate the validation basis for the complete device |
| Original test scope unclear | Request supplementary information or appropriate validation |
When Can Existing Evidence Be Retained?
If the replacement component does not alter the key technical conditions covered by the original test evidence, and the manufacturer can demonstrate its suitability through reliable design documentation, product identification, and technical evaluation, the original test evidence may continue to serve as part of the basis for the new configuration.
However, this does not mean that the original report can be directly applied to all replacement options.
The final determination must be made in light of the specific changes and applicable standard requirements.
When Is Additional Testing Needed?
If the replacement clamps alter significant conductive structures, contact methods, or the connection configuration of the complete equipment, and the original test data cannot support these changes, the appropriate scope of supplementary verification must be determined.
Relevant technical content in IEC 61230:2008 includes:
- Clause 4.6: Clamps.
- Clause 5.6: Tests on Clamps, Permanent Connection Points, and Connections.
- Clause 5.7: Short-Circuit Current Test.
- Clause 5.7.5: Documentation and Evaluation of the Test.
- Clause 6: Conformity Assessment.
- Clause 7: Modifications.
These provisions provide the standard basis for evaluating alternative clamping configurations.
It is important to note that the scope of supplementary validation should not be determined solely by procurement personnel based on experience, but rather by the manufacturer’s technical lead, the applicable testing laboratory, and the project’s authorized auditor, based on the specific circumstances.
How to Approve an Alternative Clamp Configuration Before Production?
When a supplier proposes an alternative solution, it is recommended to complete the review according to the following process.
Supplier Proposal
The supplier submits the alternative clamp model, technical specifications, product drawings, and the rationale for the change.
Technical Comparison
Conduct an item-by-item comparison between the original clamp and the alternative clamp to identify changes in materials, structure, contact surfaces, and connection methods.
Test Evidence Review
Review the test reports for the original components and the complete equipment to confirm that the test scope covers the alternative configuration.
Additional Verification
If existing evidence is insufficient, request that the supplier provide supplementary information or complete appropriate verification.
Revised Documentation
Update the assembly drawing, BOM, technical deviation notes, and configuration version records.
Formal Approval
Review and approve in writing by the authorized personnel designated by the project.
Production Release
Production may only proceed according to the final approved configuration.
If the alternative has not yet completed the necessary technical validation and project approval, it should not be treated as an approved production configuration.
What Should Be Checked After the Alternative Clamp Is Approved?
After the alternative clamp has passed technical approval, it is also necessary to ensure that the equipment actually produced and delivered conforms to the approved configuration.
The purchaser can focus on verifying the following:
- Whether the Clamp Model matches the approved model.
- Whether the Clamp Marking is correct.
- Whether the Cable Connection complies with the approved drawings.
- Whether the Ferrule and Lug match the approved BOM.
- Whether the assembly drawing is the latest revision.
- Whether the test evidence corresponds to the final approved configuration.
- Whether the product identification is traceable.
If component changes occur again in the actual delivered product, the changes must be re-evaluated; suppliers should not be allowed to adjust other components on their own simply because an alternative solution was previously approved once.
For comprehensive factory acceptance testing, refer to Portable Earthing Set Factory Acceptance Test Checklist.
For pre-production reviews of drawings, BOMs, and technical deviations, please refer to Portable Earthing Set Drawing Approval Checklist.
Conclusion: Verify the Evidence Before Accepting an Alternative Earthing Clamp
Replacing the earthing clamp in a portable earthing set is not merely a change to a single mechanical component; it may also alter the original equipment’s connection structure and test configuration.
Purchasing personnel cannot determine whether an alternative is equivalent based solely on the clamp’s appearance, opening dimensions, materials, or mounting interfaces.
What truly needs to be confirmed is whether the replacement clamp and its connecting components meet the original technical requirements, and whether the existing IEC 61230 test evidence remains applicable to the modified, complete equipment.
For alternatives proposed by suppliers, component specifications, connection structures, short-circuit withstand capabilities, test reports, and the revised BOM should be verified. Only after sufficient technical evidence has been provided and project approval has been completed can the new configuration be adopted as an officially approved production and delivery solution.
JINPOWER offers a variety of Portable Earthing and Short-Circuiting Kits that allow you to confirm the type of earthing clamp, cable specifications, connection structures, and complete equipment configuration based on project requirements. For projects with special technical requirements, we recommend finalizing the confirmation of model numbers, drawings, BOMs, and test data prior to production to minimize subsequent technical discrepancies and delivery risks.


